-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 10 Sep 2010
Google's top legal man wants to see pressure applied to governments - such as China's and Turkey's - that have strict internet censorship rules in place.
According to Reuters, David Drummond argued at a public meeting with US Trade Rep Ron Kirk and other Mountain View wonks at the Googleplex on Wednesday that such behaviour by individual countries was bad for US trade.
"Internet censorship is really a trade barrier, and is operating that way for US companies that are trying to do business abroad," he grumbled.
"If this were happening with physical trade and manufacturing goods, we'd all be saying this violates trade agreements pretty fundamentally."
His remarks probably won't be welcomed by Beijing officials, who in July renewed the ad broker's licence in China, after getting Google to agree to halt the automatic rerouting of its Google.cn search engine users to Hong Kong.
-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 10 Sep 2010
SEATTLE: Google Inc's legal chief called for pressure on governments that censor the Internet, such as China and Turkey, arguing that their blocking access to websites not only violates human rights but unfairly restrains U.S. trade. The remarks, by Google Chief Legal Officer David Drummond, mark a new economic theme in the Web company's campaign for an unrestricted Internet, and may inflame a touchy relationship with China, after the company threatened to stop censoring online searches there earlier this year.
"Internet censorship is really a trade barrier, and is operating that way for U.S. companies that are trying to do business abroad," Drummond said at a public meeting with U.S. Trade Representative Ron Kirk and other corporate executives at Google's headquarters in California's Silicon Valley. "If this were happening with physical trade and manufacturing goods, we'd all be saying this violates trade agreements pretty fundamentally."
Google's Drummond said a large and growing number of countries are now censoring the Internet in a variety of ways, for economic as well as political reasons. As an example, he said, Google's YouTube online video service was blocked in more than 20 countries and has been banned in Turkey for two years. "In our view at Google it's high time for us to start really sinking our teeth into this one," said Drummond. "We have great opportunities now with pending trade agreements to start putting some pressure on countries to recognize that Internet freedom not only is a core value -- that we should be holding them to account from a human rights standpoint -- but also that if you want to be part of the community of free trade, you are going to have to find a way to allow the Internet to be open."
-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 08 Sep 2010
Uproar this year over an “Internet Kill Switch” bill has largely subsided because the legislation has stalled in the Senate. The summer controversy focused on a proposed presidential power to declare a national emergency and shut down parts of the Web dealing with “critical infrastructure,” for up to four weeks — which under a willing White House legal adviser, critics said, might lead to Chinese-style Web censorship for political enemies.
Actually, the bill was never so specific.
Sen. Joe Lieberman and its other sponsors in the Senate have argued the Protecting Cyberspace As a National Asset Act has no “kill switch” provision, only a sort of emergency-brake feature for the president in case of cyberwar. Or something.
“What authority the government would have is not laid out at all in the law,” said Michelle Richardson, an ACLU lawyer tasked with tracking the bill. Adam Cohen was right last month when he argued in Time that the bill’s language had to be far more precise before people start to freak out (on one hand) or Congress allows it to become law (on the other).
But Chinese-style censorship already exists in the West. Germany has blocked Holocaust-deniers from its patch of the Internet since the ’90s. In February, the Berlin government passed a more sinister law meant to keep child pornography away from German screens. The law allows the Bundeskriminalamt (BKA), a sort of German FBI, to compile secret lists of outlawed sites. The law will be reviewed for its effectiveness after one year.
-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 08 Sep 2010
IN recent weeks, freedom of speech has been on my mind a lot. It’s hard not to think about it, what with radio deejays and a newspaper editor getting suspended, and a rapper getting investigated over a YouTube video.
Some of my formative years were spent in the US where freedom of speech is guaranteed by the First Amendment of the US Constitution. It is guaranteed to the point where neo-Nazis have the right to hold public rallies and demonstrators can burn the American flag without fear of being arrested. But of course there are limits.
Freedom of speech doesn’t allow for child pornography, for example, because child pornography is illegal. Freedom of speech also doesn’t allow someone to falsely shout "fire" in a crowded cinema as it could cause a stampede. Lastly, it goes without saying that freedom of speech does not allow one to defame another.
But freedom of speech in the US does include offensive speech. So, you can make fun of the president and even insult him if you want to. That’s pretty hard to imagine in Malaysia although technically we are supposed to have freedom of speech. It is protected under Article 10 of the Federal Constitution which also guarantees the right to peaceful assembly. So, we should be able to say whatever we want and hold gatherings whenever we want, right? Wrong.
Unlike the First Amendment, Article 10 entitles citizens to such freedoms only insofar as they are not restricted by the government (as opposed to those freedoms being absolutely guaranteed as in the US).
In Malaysia, we have the Sedition Act 1948 which curtails free speech and the Police Act 1967 which prohibits the gathering of three or more people in a public place without a permit.
A common joke among editors is that in Malaysia there is freedom of speech but not necessarily freedom after speech. The reason often given by those who are against US-style freedom of speech is that we are a multiracial country and therefore have to be extra careful about what we say.
-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 08 Sep 2010
In the latest episode of internet censorship in Oman, the Telecom Regulation Authority of Oman has announced its plans to completely ban the use of Virtual Private Networks (VPN) and would require companies to acquire the TRA's permission before they can use them. The new regulation has not been passed yet and has been posted by the TRA online for public consultation.
The use of VPN by consumers has increased over the years as it is the only way for internet users in Oman to use VoIP services - which have been banned in Oman for a number of years now. Some VPN protocols such as PPTP are already completely blocked in Oman and providers of other VPN solutions are increasingly discovered by the ISP and are blocked on individual basis.
-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 07 Sep 2010
There’s uproar among the youth in Turkmenistan today after the government decided to ban the popular social networking site, agent.mail.ru. Currently, it’s inaccessible via both TM Cell and MTS (about whom I’ve reported before). The website had eventually experienced a small surge in Turkmen users, especially young men and women who used it to get to know each other.
It’s an open secret that one of the main purposes of agent.mail.ru is dating. The site certainly facilitates meeting potential partners: just type in the city, gender, and age in the search engine, and within only a few seconds, voila! Lovely, smiling faces appear. You can even find young women in bikini shots or Odalisque poses — some as young as 16! Another big advantage is the availability of chat rooms, which are easy even for the less techno-savvy to use, and is cheaper in the long run than mobile phones.
-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 07 Sep 2010
LABOR'S controversial internet filter plan faces near-death despite the ascension of Julia Gillard as Australia's 28th prime minister.
Ms Gillard won the backing of independent MPs turned powerbrokers Tony Windsor and Rob Oakeshott despite Bob Katter supporting the Coalition and Tony Abbott.
The country has been in limbo since the August 21 poll didn't deliver an outright winner.
Labor went into the 2007 election pledging to censor the internet but since then Communications Minister Stephen Conroy has changed the shape of his plan several times. At last count Senator Conroy ordered a 12-month review into how refused classification content is rated.
Labor's mandatory filtering program will force all internet service providers to block web pages rated as refused classification on a secret blacklist.
-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 07 Sep 2010
At midnight on a brisk February evening, Imad al-Ash heard a knock at his door. He opened it to find what many Jordanians fear most — a force of nearly 40 agents from the country’s shadowy intelligence organization, known here as the mukhabarat.
Falling on the wrong side of the mukhabarat — which performs both international and domestic intelligence — strikes terror into even the most hardened enemies of Jordan.
But Al-Ash was far from the typical religious extremist or criminal that might draw the agency’s attention. A fifth year computer science student at the University of Jordan, he was not an activist and, although a devout Muslim, he steered clear of fundamentalist groups.
-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 07 Sep 2010
Mocking officials online, exposing high-level corruption and discussing political tension could land journalists in many autocratic Middle East states in jail.
But Jordan's leading news website www.Ammonnews.net doesn't shy away from hectoring the government over misappropriation of funds by senior officials or highlighting fault lines between the country's Palestinian population and indigenous Jordanians.
"We draw our strength from the street... We are the true mirror of what is under the ashes, what no one dares talk about," said Samir Hiyari, publisher of the portal which now boasts 250,000 daily visits and earns a growing stream of advertising revenue from the country's top corporations.
-
By: Jillian C. York
Date: 07 Sep 2010
Craigslist left everyone guessing why the site decided to close its adult services section on Friday by replacing the steamy destination with a "censored" banner. The online classifieds Website took action without releasing a statement and has so far refused comment. Craigslist's adult services section housed sexually explicit ads for escorts, masseuses and similar content. The move comes after 17 state attorneys general pressured the site to stop displaying its adult services section.
Without a definitive answer, Craigslist's abrupt move has left others to fill in the blanks about the shutdown. Some say it's a protest meant to draw attention to the site's first amendment rights. Others wonder if it isn't a strategic ploy to appease advocacy groups and law enforcement. It is also possible Craigslist simply doesn't have the wherewithal to face off against a potential 17 state attorneys general in court.